Two class-action lawsuits filed earlier this month allege several U.S. airlines and ATPCO of using nonpublic shopping and pricing data to coordinate fares in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act.
The first suit was filed Nov. 3 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia and names ATPCO and its subsidiary 3Victors, which it acquired in 2023, American Airlines, Delta Air Lines, Southwest Airlines, Alaska Airlines and JetBlue as defendants. The second suit was filed Nov. 4 in U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington and names the same defendants as in the first suit, plus United Airlines and Hawaiian Airlines.
Each lawsuit focuses on 3Victors' Iris and PriceEye products, which plaintiffs allege operate together as a price-monitoring system.
The Washington suit alleges that Iris is a central data repository that pools shopping data and dynamic prices straight from participating airlines' internal systems into a single, standardized stream, and that PriceEye is an analytics dashboard.
It further alleges that ATPCO does not just sell this market intelligence, but that participation in Iris is based on a "give-to-get" model, in which "airlines that contribute their own proprietary dynamic pricing data to Iris" are rewarded with PriceEye's "pricing alerts," "competitive benchmarking" and "anomaly detection."
The Virginia suit alleges that the defendant airlines supply 3Victors with their confidential flight shopping data, revealing itineraries for which travelers are searching and the fares the airline offers in response. "This information exposes emerging demand before it appears in bookings and shows how each airline prices flights to capture that demand," according to the filing. "3Victors then pools the data and provides participating airlines with a real-time view of competitors' fares and changes in traveler demand."
The suit alleges that the airlines use this intelligence to set their own fares, continually informed by customer demand and pricing information supplied by their rivals, and therefore have "agreed to operate as a cartel, using ATPCO and 3Victors to coordinate pricing among otherwise competing carriers."
Each suit argues that this information exchange enables the airlines to inflate the cost of airfares. The plaintiffs seek damages and an injunction stopping the alleged exchange.
When ATPCO acquired 3Victors in December 2023 the company indicated it would use new datasets, machine learning and artificial intelligence to enhance retailing solutions.
But this isn't the first antitrust lawsuit against ATPCO and U.S. airlines.
The Department of Justice on Dec. 21, 1992, sued ATPCO and eight airlines, alleging "ATPCO's reports 'allow the airline defendants to monitor and analyze immediately each other's fare changes,' and that the airlines used ATPCO to 'exchange[] proposals to change fares and negotiate[] increases to fares,' " according to the Virginia filing.
The Washington filing also referenced the prior lawsuit and noted that the DOJ alleged that "from April 1988 through at least May 1990, the airline defendants used ATPCO to exchange proposals for fare increases, to negotiate them, and to give one another assurances about their size and timing."
The suit was settled in two separate decrees in 1993 and 1994, with limitations on what the airlines could learn about each other through ATPCO. Each decree expired 10 years after being enacted.
The Virginia suit now alleges that ATPCO's business has expanded "from collecting and distributing airlines' filed fares and rules to collecting and distributing the data and tools airlines use to inform their pricing decisions."
The Washington suit alleges that "the airlines have resurrected their arrangement. … Through APTCO, the defendants have engineered a new, highly sophisticated information exchange to monitor one another's pricing and artificially inflate the cost of air travel for millions of Americans."
In a statement shared with BTN, ATPCO said "we have reviewed the complaints. ATPCO denies the allegations, and we plan to defend ourselves vigorously against them."
Airlines for America, the U.S. carrier lobbying group, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.