Shelter Island, NY Area Hotels

Name by letter
Click the letter below to show only hotels starting with that letter. You may also type all or part of a hotel name in the box above to find all hotels that contain the entered name. A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z ALL
Hotel Preferences
Meal Plans Offered
Hotel Type
Number of Rooms

Set Search Radius
0 miles
Drag or click to zoom in or out the search radius. Only Hotels that fall within 20 miles from the city center will be shown.
Choose Your View
Topping Rose HouseOne Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpik
Bridgehampton, NY 11932
22 Rooms

This 22 room property, renovated in 2012......

Commission: 10%$395-$3,000(USD)
DetailsView on Map
8Moderate Deluxe
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa290 Old Montauk Hwy
Montauk, NY 11954
146 Rooms

Beachfront Resort & Health/Beauty Spa on 10 acres, 5 miles from train station & 15 miles from East Hampton Airport....

Commission: 10%$650-$900(USD)
DetailsView on Map
6First Class
The American Hotel49 Main St PO Box 1349
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
8 Rooms

1800's inn - Located on Main St....

DetailsView on Map
6First Class
Bee & Thistle Inn100 Lyme St
Old Lyme, CT 06371
10 Rooms

Quaint Colonial Country Inn, housed in a restored private home dating from 1756....

Commission: 10%$139-$204(USD)
DetailsView on Map
6First Class
Copper Beech Inn46 Main St
Ivoryton, CT 06442
22 Rooms

Rambling Victorian Inn comprising country home & carriage house, both dating from the 1880s....

Commission: 10%$179-$329(USD)
DetailsView on Map
6First Class
Griswold Inn36 Main St
Essex, CT 06426
39 Rooms

Picturesque Inn dating from 1776 with colonial maritime atmosphere....

DetailsView on Map
6First Class
Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites1707 Old Country Rd, Rte 58
Riverhead, NY 11901
89 Rooms

This 89 room property, renovated in 2014......

Commission: 10%$189-$1,300(USD)
DetailsView on Map
6First Class
Holiday Inn New London North Hotel35 Governor Winthrop Blvd
New London, CT 06320
120 Rooms

Five-story Full Service Hotel located downtown, adjacent to Garde Performing Arts Center & 10 minutes from Mystic attractions....

Commission: 10%$89-$197(USD)
DetailsView on Map
6First Class
Hyatt Place Long Island/East End451 E Main St
Riverhead, NY 11901
100 Rooms

Chic, contemprary hotel located in the heart of Riverhead; situated along the Peconic River....

Commission: 10%$99-$499(USD)
DetailsView on Map
6First Class
Hotel Indigo East End1830 W Main St
Riverhead, NY 11901-3120
100 Rooms

On Long Island's East End in heart of North Fork and Hamptons - Tanger Outlets Riverhead next door, numerous wineries nearby....

Commission: 10%$225-$459(USD)
DetailsView on Map